On Tuesday the NFLPA filed its brief in the Tom Brady case and, according to court documents obtained by CBSSports.com, it includes a full 457-page transcript of the Brady appeal hearing between the Patriots quarterback and Roger Goodell.
The NFL and NFLPA previously agreed to a confidentiality agreement. However, Judge Richard Berman, in requesting 15-page reply briefs from each side, said he has "always had considerable difficulty approving any sealed documents" due to the "keen public interest in these matters and the public's right to know."
The biggest issue for the public in the entire Deflategate saga? The evidence against Brady used by the league to uphold a four-game suspension. A lot of that is now in the public thanks to the filing of the entire appeal testimony in this case.
It includes the following:
• Brady says he never previously knew the name of Jim McNally, the alleged 'Deflator'
• He also says he wasn't concerned that McNally referred to himself as the 'Deflator' in texts
Tom Brady reacts to questions about the 'deflator' texts pic.twitter.com/REfTWl5Fw0
— Sean Leahy (@leahysean) August 4, 2015
• Brady's team argued that Brett Favre not turning over his phone to the NFL created a precedent for fines, but not a suspension
Tom Brady's lawyers brought up Brett Favre's sexting scandal... pic.twitter.com/e3AalDTEi1
— Matt Miller (@nfldraftscout) August 4, 2015
•Brady says was never told by investigator Ted Wells that he could be disciplined for not turning over texts or emails
Brady says he would have given over phone above lawyer's objection if Wells told him he'd be disciplined for it pic.twitter.com/i5KGyvQRMB
— Sean Leahy (@leahysean) August 4, 2015
• And, Wells himself said the same: "I did not tell Mr. Brady at any time that he would be subject to punishment for not turning over the documents. I did not say anything like that."
• Wells did say, however, that Brady not turning over his phone made him question the QB's credibility
Wells taking a shot at Brady advisors here.. pic.twitter.com/pj2Ml86lEs
— Andrew Brandt (@adbrandt) August 4, 2015
Wells also explains how he came to his conclusion that Brady 'more probably than not' knew of football tampering
Wells explaining 'more probable than not' standard. Clearly ticked off re criticism. pic.twitter.com/SuJX1sTn0s
— Andrew Brandt (@adbrandt) August 4, 2015
• Troy Vincent acknowledges players do not receive the Game Day Operations Manual (and was never given a Manual as a player)
• Brady told Goodell, however, that the Pats had given refs a copy of the PSI Rule in October
• Brady and commissioner Roger Goodell also discuss inflation ranges and the process that goes into preparing game balls.
Brady talks about how he grips the football pic.twitter.com/oBxGFtQTf5
— Ben Volin (@BenVolin) August 4, 2015
The following 172-page document is from the appeal hearing testimony:
Tom Brady appeal hearing transcripts